| Team | 2010 | 2011 | 2012 |
| Anaheim | + COL #4, DET #4, CGY #4, PIT#4, NYI #5, DET #5 | + NYI #2, NYR #3, NYI #3, DET #5 | + |
| - | - #1, #3 | - | |
| Boston | + TOR #2, FLO #3 | + | + |
| - #2, #3 | - | - | |
| Buffalo | + BOS #3 | + PHI #2 | + |
| - #3 | - | - | |
| Calgary | + | + | + |
| - #4, #5 | - | - | |
| Carolina | + PHI #2, LAK #2, LAK #5 | + NYI #1, LAK #1, LAK #2, CHI #2, LAK #3, WSH #4 | + LAK #3, EDM #4 |
| - #2 | - #2, #3 | - #2 | |
| Chicago | + TOR #1, PIT #1, NYI #2 | + | + NYI #4, PIT #5 |
| - #2, #4, #5 | - #1, #2 | - | |
| Colorado | + LAK #3, DET #3 | + ANA #3, NYI #5 | + |
| - #4, #5 | - | - | |
| Dallas | + MTL #1, VCR #3 | + | + |
| - #4, #5 | - #2 | - | |
| Detroit | + MTL #2, FLO #2, STL #3 | + VCR #2 | + |
| - #2, #3, #4, #5 | - #4, #5 | - | |
| Edmonton | + CAR #2, PHI #3 | + PHI #3 | + CAR #2 |
| - #2, #4 | - #4 | - #4 | |
| Florida | + TOR #2, PHX #3, LAK #4, DAL #5, CGY #5, PHI #5 | + PHX #3, PIT #5 | + |
| - #2, #3, #4, #5 | - #3, #4 | - | |
| Los Angeles | + MTL #4, MTL #5 | + CAR #2, TOR #4 | + PHI #5 |
| - #1, #2, #3, #4, #5 | - #1, #2, #3 | - #3 | |
| Montreal | + PIT #2, STL #4, NJD #4, FLO #4, PHX #5 | + PHI #1, CAR #3 | + |
| - #1, #2, #3, #4, #5 | - #1, #2, #4 | - | |
| New Jersey | + PHI #4 | + | + |
| - #4 | - | - | |
| New York I | + STL #2, CHI #4, CHI #5 | + | + |
| - #1, #2, #4, #5 | - #1, #2, #3, #5 | - #4 | |
| New York R | + PHI #1, TOR #4 | + ANA #1 | + |
| - #3, #5 | - #3 | - | |
| Philadelphia | + MTL #3, DAL #4 | + FLO #4 | + |
| - #1, #2, #3, #4, #5 | - #1, #2, #3, #5 | - #5 | |
| Phoenix | + EDM #2, EDM #4, FLO #5 | + DAL #2, MTL #4 | + |
| - #3, #5 | - #3 | - | |
| Pittsburgh | + VCR #1, CHI #2 | + CHI #1, VCR #1 | + |
| - #1, #2, #4 | - #5 | - #5 | |
| San Jose | + COL #5 | + FLO #3 | + |
| - | - | - | |
| St. Louis | + LAK #1, DET #2, NYI #4 | + DET #4 | + |
| - #2, #3, #4 | - | - | |
| Toronto | + BUF #3, NYR #5 | + EDM #4, PHI #5 | + |
| - #1, #2, #4 | - #4 | - | |
| Vancouver | + NYI #1 | + | + |
| - #1, #3 | - #1, #2 | - | |
| Washington | + NYR #3 | + MTL #1, MTL #2 | + |
| - | - #4 | - |